Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Goodfellas Pizzeria. We'd love to have your feedback!

Select a location

You are submitting your information to Goodfellas Pizzeria and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. Popmenu's and apply.

Our Latest Reviews

Kevin 1 day ago

Paulie's Favorite

The pizza was delicious as usual! We love a pizza box we can barely fit through our door! Everyone was well fed!

Stephanie 2 days ago

The Don

Loved it!

Alex 7 days ago

22" Half & Half Pie

Pizza was great, love the flavor, cheese sticks were also excellent. Best pizza place we've visited in Cincinnati

David 8 days ago

22" Half & Half Pie

Great pizza, friendly service

Ian 8 days ago


I've had the pizza many times now and I love it. Got it for the work crew for lunch on Friday and they loved it. Would recommend to anyone who loves a good slice.

Michelle 2 days ago

12" Half & Half Pie

Always great!

Steph 2 days ago

Caprese Salad


Brandi 7 days ago

12" Pie

Pizza was great. Loved the laid back atmosphere. Goodfellas is the only pizza my 2.5 yr son likes!

Keri 8 days ago


Excellent pizza and breadsticks. Staff was very friendly!

Steve 8 days ago

16" Half & Half Pie

Delicious workers are always friendly and accomodating.