Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Goodfellas Pizzeria. We'd love to have your feedback!

Select a location

You are submitting your information to Goodfellas Pizzeria and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. Popmenu's and apply.

Our Latest Reviews

John 4 days ago

The Vinny

Along with the 16in Vinny, we also ordered a 22in pepperoni and meatball. Both were excellent along with being ready on time. Great pizza and service make Goodfellas (Baxter Ave) our go to choice!

Sarah 8 days ago

The Vinny

We love this place! Great food and great environment.

Justin 12 days ago

12" Half & Half Pie


Caleb Aaron 15 days ago

12" Pie

Good pizza

Robert 18 days ago

12" Half & Half Pie

The pizza was delicious! We were out of towners and were treated like we were repeat customers. We will be back!

Lucas 7 days ago

16" Half & Half Pie

We were craving some thin crust NY style pizza and after some quick research found this. The pizza absolutely hit the spot and was delicious! We also arrived early for pickup and the pizza was already made, great service. Thanks!

Daran 10 days ago

22" Pie

Had the cheese bread too. Easy to order and ready ahead of time. Glad you have two locations in Lexington, too!

De John 13 days ago

22" Half & Half Pie


Jason 16 days ago

22" Pie

We ordered the 22 " pie with pepperoni. It was delicious as always and ready for pickup right on time.

Ashley 19 days ago


It was amazing!